The Troubled Life of Stephen J. Olson — Part II

Stephen J. Olson, my client’s grandfather, fled from Boston in late 1920, after jumping bail on a charge that he fathered the child of a 15-year-old girl (see my last post). He next appears in records in his marriage to my client’s grandmother Agnes McLain. They were married in Philadelphia on Jan. 23, 1923. On Dec. 27, 1923, their oldest daughter Doris was born, then Evelyn on Feb. 4, 1926, and then Velma on July 14, 1928. In 1928, they are listed in the Baltimore City Directory at 1011 East Biddle. Stephen’s occupation is listed as a chauffeur. Sometime in 1928, Stephen left the home. Agnes, now with three daughters age 5 and younger, still lived on East Biddle until 1930, when she moved back to her mother’s home on Wilcox Street.

Meanwhile, Stephen next appeared in records on Jan. 30, 1930, when he married Birdie Wells in Wilmington, Delaware. Five weeks later, he pleaded guilty to a charge of bigamy. He was fined $400 and sentenced to one year in jail to be served at the New Castle County Workhouse.

New Castle County Court of General Sessions, Sessions Dockets, March Term 1930 -January Term 1931, 2805.15, pg. 12.

After his release from jail, Stephen & Birdie began to make a life in Salisbury, Maryland. Twin boys were born on March 3, 1932. They were named Stephen Joseph Olson, Jr and Zedok Henry Olson, after Birdie’s father. However, tragically, little Zedok died of pneumonia on Jan. 14, 1934 at the age of one year and 10 months. Apparently the marriage began to fall apart after that. Birdie sued Stephen for divorce on Oct. 10, 1944, on the grounds of abandonment.

In a deposition that was taken from Birdie in her lawyer’s office, she said that they were married in Baltimore on Jan. 26, 1930, and lived there for about 13 months before they moved to Salisbury. This was actually the time during which Stephen was in jail for bigamy. However, his jail time and the fact that he was still married to his first wife Agnes, my client’s grandmother, as the deposition was being taken, was never mentioned.

Birdie stated in her deposition that after the birth of her son, she became afflicted with arthritis, and that her husband Stephen became uninterested in her, and started “going around with other women”. The fact that there was another son, and that he died, was never mentioned. Birdie also stated that, under an agreement they made in “Peoples Court”, Stephen had been paying $3.00 per week for the support of Stephen, Jr.  Her lawyer asked if she was satisfied with that, and she stated, “Three dollars a week is not very much on which to keep a boy 12 years old. Mr. Olson works and makes at least $25.00 a week and should be able to pay $5.00 a week.”

A divorce decree was issued on Dec. 14, 1944. Child support payments were kept at $3.00 per week.

In 1946, two years after his divorce from Birdie, Stephen apparently wanted to finally take care of the fact that, 18 years after their separation, a year in jail and one full marriage and divorce later, he was still married to his first wife Agnes. There may have been another woman in the picture by that point. It is uncertain when he married  his third wife  Minnie,  but records indicate that he was married by 1948,  so it could very well be that she was in the picture in 1946.  In any case,  Stephen now had grounds for divorce under Maryland law, that being his and Agnes’s separation for over 5 years. (Prior to the “no-fault” divorce laws enacted in the 1960s & 1970s, in most states, including Maryland, in order to have grounds to get a divorce, you had to either prove marital fault on the part of the other person, e.g., adultery, abandonment, cruelty, etc., or you had to show that you had been living apart voluntarily for some number of years — in Maryland, that number was five).  So, in Maryland, if the time of voluntary separation had been less than five years, you couldn’t get a divorce unless your spouse committed a marital crime, or agreed to the divorce. And the person committing the marital crime couldn’t get a divorce unless the spouse agreed.  And clearly Agnes had not agreed early on. Hence, the bigamy.

But at that point, 18 years after their separation, Stephen then had grounds for a divorce, and Agnes didn’t have a legal leg to stand on. And she had gone for a very long time here without getting alimony, common those days, or presumably, child support. The daughters were then 23, 20 & 18. So, before the actual divorce proceedings began, on Aug. 21, 1946, Agnes & Stephen entered into a contract. Stephen paid $200, which was put into escrow for Agnes. He also agreed to pay an additional $1800, payable in weekly installments of $10 per week until it was paid (about 3 ½ years). They didn’t call it alimony, and Agnes gave up any right to file any claim for alimony or support or maintenance. She gave up any rights as a widow and any rights to any of his property. She agreed that she would answer a divorce claim and would submit to the passage of a divorce decree. Stephen agreed to pay all court costs and the costs of both his lawyer and her lawyer.

Many untruths were spoken in depositions in the subsequent divorce case that Agnes has agreed, by contract, to submit to. The fact that Stephen was married to Birdie during his and Agnes’ marriage and that he served time in prison for bigamy was never mentioned. The fact that the separation was not “voluntary” on the part of Agnes was not mentioned.

In any case, the contract between Stephen and Agnes was signed on Aug. 21, 1946. The divorce was decreed, finally, in Nov. 1946. Stephen went on to marry a woman named Minnie. He passed away on Nov. 8, 1967 in Salisbury.

Sources: Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, Marriage Index, 1885-1951, Ancestry.com, 2011, Provo, UT, USA.                                                                                                                             Delaware Marriage Records, 1806-1933, Ancestry.com, 2010, Provo, UT, USA.
U.S., Find A Grave Index, 1600s-Current, Ancestry.com, 2012, Provo, UT, USA.
1930 United States Federal Census, Baltimore, Baltimore (Independent City), Maryland; Roll: 853; Page: 4B; Enumeration District: 0117; Image: 467.0; FHL microfilm: 2340588, Ancestry.com, 2002, Provo, UT, USA.
New Castle County Court of General Sessions, Sessions Dockets, March Term 1930 -January Term 1931, 2805.15, pg. 12.
New Castle County Workhouse, Board of Trustees, Commitment Book, 1918 – 1939.
New Castle County Workhouse, Board of Trustees, Discharge Book, Vol I, 1918 – 1950.
The Cornell Daily Sun, Volume 55, Number 89, January 23, 1935.
Daily Illini, July 31, 1932.
U.S. City Directories, 1822-1995, Baltimore, Maryland, Baltimore Historical Society, Baltimore, Maryland.
U.S. City Directories, 1822-1995, Baltimore, Maryland, Ancestry.com, 2011, Provo, UT, USA.
State of Maryland, Certificate of Death #66927, Zedok Henry Olson, Jan. 14, 1934, Archives of Maryland, Annapolis, Maryland.
Circuit Court for Wicomico County and State of Maryland, No. 6830 Chancery, Birdie Ella Olson vs. Stephen Joseph Olson, Bill of Complaint for Divorce, Oct. 10, 1944, Archives of Maryland, Annapolis, Maryland.
Circuit Court for Wicomico County and State of Maryland, No. 6830 Chancery, Birdie Ella Olson vs. Stephen Joseph Olson, Examiner’s Return, Nov 30, 1944, Archives of Maryland, Annapolis, Maryland.
Circuit Court for Wicomico County and State of Maryland, No. 6830 Chancery, Birdie Ella Olson vs. Stephen Joseph Olson, Decree of Divorce, Dec. 14, 1944, Archives of Maryland, Annapolis, Maryland.
Circuit Court for Wicomico County and State of Maryland, No. 7390 Chancery, Stephen J. Olson vs. Agnes Olson, Complaint, Sept. 9, 1946, Archives of Maryland, Annapolis, Maryland.                                                                                                                                       Circuit Court for Wicomico County and State of Maryland, No. 7390 Chancery, Stephen J. Olson vs. Agnes Olson, Examiner’s Return, Oct, 23, 1946, Archives of Maryland, Annapolis, Maryland.
Circuit Court for Wicomico County and State of Maryland, No. 7390 Chancery, Stephen J. Olson vs. Agnes Olson, Decree of Divorce, Nov. 4, 1946, Archives of Maryland, Annapolis, Maryland.
Circuit Court for Wicomico County and State of Maryland, No. 7390 Chancery, Stephen J. Olson vs. Agnes Olson, Agreement and Power of Attorney, Nov. 4, 1946, Archives of Maryland, Annapolis, Maryland.

The Troubled Life of Stephen J. Olson — Part I

“I know nothing about my family history, except that my grandfather ran out on his wife and family when my mother was a girl,” a client from Baltimore told me on our first meeting. “He started a new family in Salisbury . . .” His voice trailed off. “That’s about all I know.”

So began my search which would eventually lead to a family tree that included, among others, a Civil War soldier, a Pennsylvania Dutch family with American origins dating to the mid-1700s, an Irish immigrant from Kiltyclogher in County Leitrim (the daughter of parents who lived through the Great Famine), a Scots-Irish immigrant to Baltimore around 1800, many early deaths of children and spouses, and a number of underage marriages and divorces when that was not common. And the kicker was the story of the grandfather who had run out on his family, who I discovered had been in jail in two states. His story is told here:

Stephen Joseph Olson, my client’s grandfather, was born in the East End of Boston on the day after Christmas in 1900, the first child of Olaf & Rose (Gallagher) Olson (who will be featured in a future blog post), immigrants from Norway and Ireland. His birth record taken at the time clearly shows that he was born on the 26th, but by the time he was 9, he and his family had already adopted Christmas Day as his birthday — one of the quirky little things that happened frequently in the days before record-keeping became as exact as it is today.

It is clear that Stephen’s early life was challenging, as the family struggled economically and with illness and death. He was the oldest of four sons born to his parents, but two of his brothers died as children — Joseph, in 1908 at the age of 3 from meningitis, when Stephen was 7; and then Andrew, in 1909 at the age of 1 year and 9 months from gastro enteritis, when Stephen was 8. He also lost three of his uncles who were living in his neighborhood in Boston, all before he had reached the age of 7. And then, the ultimate loss, that of his mother Rose (Gallagher) Olson in 1908, when she was 34 and Stephen was almost 8.

The Home for Destitute Catholic Children

The family clearly struggled even more after his mother’s death. In March of 1910, Stephen, then age 9, and his little brother James, age 6, were put in an orphanage, the Home for Destitute Catholic Children. Located at 788 Harrison Avenue in Boston and staffed by the Daughters of Charity of Saint Vincent de Paul, the orphanage housed roughly 450 children at the time. Their stay was only a couple of months, but one must wonder about the impact on the two young boys, after already suffering so much tragedy in their young lives.

Their lives likely stabilized somewhat upon their father’s re-marriage to a widow named Frances Nugent. However, given that she brought two children into the marriage, and she and their father Olaf went on to have additional children, one can suspect that there was additional strain on the family.

At any rate, in 1919, at the age of 18, Stephen Olson’s life took another decidedly negative turn. Boston court records reveal that Stephen was arrested on the charge of “getting a woman with child, he not being her husband”. This was a crime in the Commonwealth of Massachusetts at the time, as it was in many states. The arrest was likely further prompted by the fact that the mother of the child, Violet Courier, was only 15 years old at the time. While a charge of statutory rape was not made, probably because Stephen was just over the age of maturity himself, authorities during that era often prosecuted such cases to try to ensure the support of the child.

While the exact date of arrest is unknown, Stephen is listed on the 1920 Census, taken on Jan. 8th, as an inmate at the Suffolk County Jail (see sidebar). The child, Paula Courier, was born Jan. 25, 1920. Stephen was brought from the Suffolk County Jail into Superior Court on Feb. 2. He pleaded guilty, and the judge placed him on probation and ordered him to post a bond of $300 to ensure his further appearance before the Court.

The Suffolk County Jail, located at 215 Charles Street, Boston, near Beacon Hill, where Stephen Olson spent an unknown number of days and nights, has a fascinating history. Opened in 1851, over the course of its life as a jail, it housed many famous felons including James Michael Curley, Malcolm X, and anarchists Sacco and Vanzetti. Treatment there was notorious, and in 1973, a court ruled that because of overcrowding, the jail violated the constitutional rights of its prisoners. It was not officially closed until 1990. The building has, since then, been converted to a luxury hotel called The Liberty Hotel. They have kept the prison motif, retaining the exposed brick of the original building, and calling their restaurant “Clink”.

Apparently, the bond was not posted at that time, and the Court on April 16, 1920 again ordered him to post the $300 bond. The bond was not posted, and on July 9th, 1920 Stephen was put back in the Suffolk County Jail. This apparently got his attention and he posted the bond four days later.

On October 7th, 1920, Stephen was called into Court and did not appear. In other words, he “jumped bail”. On December 15th, 1920, the Court ordered that he be re-arrested. There are no further records in the Suffolk County Court, as he, undoubtedly, fled the state to avoid arrest. Nine days later, on Christmas Eve, 1920, the child Paula Courier died at the age of 10 months from pneumonia. The mother Violet Courier, went on to marry years later and she had another daughter.

So ended a troubled time for Stephen Olson in Boston, where he likely never returned. His father, Olaf Olson, remained there until his death in 1927, as did his younger brother James, who, by all the evidence, led a very stable life there. Stephen’s life was anything but stable, as he moved from Baltimore to Wilmington to Salisbury, served an additional year in jail, and married and divorced again and again (to be covered in Part 2).

 

The Liberty Hotel

Sources: Social Security Card Application, Stephen Joseph Olson, #220-10-9825, SSA, Washington, DC.
Massachusetts, Birth Records, 1840-1915, Ancestry.com, 2013, Provo, UT, USA. Massachusetts, Death Records, 1841-1915, Ancestry.com, 2013, Provo, UT, USA.
Orphanage Record,1916, Home for Destitute Catholic Children, Stephen J. Olson & James Olson, Obtained from Catholic Charities, Boston, MA.
1910 United States Federal Census, Boston Ward 12, Suffolk, Massachusetts; Roll: T624_618; Page: 17A; Enumeration District: 1442; FHL microfilm: 1374631, Ancestry.com, 2006. Provo, UT, USA.
1920 United States Federal Census, Boston, Ward 2, Suffolk, Massachusetts; Roll: T625_728; Page: 13B; Enumeration District: 27; Image: 742, Ancestry.com, Provo, UT, USA. Superior Court, County of Suffolk, Commonwealth of Massachusetts, Commonwealth of Massachusetts vs. Stephen Olson, Complaint, Feb. 4, 1920, No. 1549.
Superior Court, County of Suffolk, Commonwealth of Massachusetts, Commonwealth of Massachusetts vs. Stephen Olson, Order of Probation, April 16, 1920, No. 1549.
Superior Court, County of Suffolk, Commonwealth of Massachusetts, Commonwealth of Massachusetts vs. Stephen Olson, Order for Re-Arrest, Dec. 15, 1920, No. 1549.
Charles Street Jail, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_Street_Jail.
The Liberty Hotel, http://www.libertyhotel.com/hotel-history.